Sometimes the most terrifying monsters don’t lurk in sewers
or haunted hotels. Sometimes they wear military uniforms and call themselves
liberators while they disappear your children in the dead of night.
In 1976, when General Jorge Rafael Videla’s jackboots came
stomping across Argentina like some fever dream out of a Kafka nightmare, the
real horror show was just beginning. Oh, they had their fancy words for it—la
guerra sucia, the dirty war—but there wasn’t anything clean about what
happened next. Kids started vanishing. Just… gone. One day Maria’s boy is
kissing her goodbye on his way to university, the next day there’s nothing but
an empty bedroom that still smells like his aftershave and the terrible,
gnawing certainty that she’ll never see him again.
You know what’s worse than a ghost? A missing child. At
least with ghosts, you know they’re dead.
The disappeared—los desaparecidos—that’s what they
called them, like using a fancy Spanish word could somehow make the horror more
palatable. But you can’t dress up evil in a tuxedo; it’s still evil underneath.
These weren’t statistics in some government filing cabinet. These were sons and
daughters, bright-eyed kids with their whole lives ahead of them, swallowed up
by the machinery of state terror like so much meat into a grinder.
But here’s the thing about mothers—and any parent reading
this will understand—we don’t give up. We can’t. It goes against our
fundamental programming, like asking the sun not to rise or telling your heart
to stop beating.
So on April 30, 1977, fourteen women showed up at the Plaza
de Mayo in Buenos Aires. Just fourteen. Ordinary women who’d been thrust into
extraordinary circumstances, wearing simple white scarves and clutching
photographs of their missing children like talismans against the dark. They
didn’t look like revolutionaries. They looked like what they were: mothers.
Tired, grief-stricken mothers who refused to let their children become just
another bureaucratic footnote.
The government probably figured they’d get tired, go home,
forget about it eventually. The way governments always figure people will just…
move on.
They figured wrong.
Every Thursday at 3:30 p.m., rain or shine, through seasons
that stretched into years that stretched into decades, the Mothers of Plaza de
Mayo kept coming. Their ranks grew. Their voices grew stronger. And their
simple, stubborn presence became something that made dictators nervous—because
there’s nothing more dangerous to a tyrant than a mother who won’t shut up
about her missing child.
Their influence spread like ripples in a dark pond, reaching
across oceans and decades to touch other mothers in other places where the
monsters wore different uniforms but carried the same stench of oppression.
---
In Indonesia, circa 1997, another kind of monster was
holding court. Suharto’s New Order regime had been squeezing the life out of
that nation for three decades, using all the classic tools: censorship,
euphemisms, and the kind of casual brutality that gets normalized when good
people stay silent too long. It was a place where speaking truth could get you
disappeared just as surely as in Argentina, where the very act of asking
questions could mark you as an enemy of the state.
But sometimes inspiration travels in mysterious ways.
At the Women’s Journal Foundation, a group of activists was
discussing violence against women when one of them—Nur Iman Subono—mentioned
the story of those Argentine mothers. You could almost hear the light bulb
clicking on in the darkness. Gadis Arivia and philosopher Karlina
Leksono-Supelli looked at each other with that peculiar recognition that passes
between people who’ve just stumbled onto something important.
By February 1998, Suara Ibu Peduli—Voice of Concerned
Mothers—was born. They understood something crucial that those Argentine women
had figured out two decades earlier: sometimes the most subversive thing you
can do is pretend to be exactly what the system expects you to be.
In Suharto’s Indonesia, mothers were supposed to be
apolitical creatures, concerned only with domestic matters—cooking, cleaning,
child-rearing. Perfect. SIP would weaponize those very expectations, turning
the stereotype into camouflage for their resistance.
Their first target was as ordinary as it gets: milk. Prices
had shot up 400 percent, and Jakarta was experiencing shortages that hit
families where it hurt most. SIP announced they’d be selling cheap milk—a
perfectly maternal concern, nothing political about it at all. Never mind that
their posters carried a delicious double meaning: “Turunkan su… su!” could mean
“Bring down milk prices!”
Or it could mean “Bring down Suharto!”
Sometimes the most effective weapons hide in plain sight.
On February 23, 1998, these Indonesian mothers marched
around the Hotel Indonesia Roundabout—a symbolic heart of Jakarta—dressed in
office attire, carrying flowers like they were heading to a garden party
instead of a revolution. They handed out flowers to soldiers and passersby,
delivering speeches with smiles on their faces and steel in their voices.
It lasted thirty minutes before the authorities pounced,
because even dictators eventually recognize rebellion when they see it, no
matter how prettily it’s packaged. Several leaders, including Karlina Supelli
and Gadis Arivia, were arrested, charged with illegal assembly, fined, and
accused of communist sympathies—that old reliable boogeyman that authoritarian
regimes trot out whenever they need to justify their brutality.
But here’s what those generals and colonels and bureaucrats
never seem to understand: arresting mothers for demanding better lives for
their children doesn’t make them go away. It just makes them angrier. And
angrier mothers, well… that’s when things get interesting.
SIP’s protests preceded the massive student demonstrations
that would finally topple Suharto in May 1998. These women helped clear the
path, proving that revolution doesn’t always announce itself with raised fists
and angry chants. Sometimes it comes quietly, wearing sensible shoes and
carrying photographs.
During those crucial days in May, SIP members distributed
food to students and the public, keeping the protests alive with the kind of
practical support that makes the difference between a flash in the pan and
lasting change. Even after Reformasi—the reform movement that brought democracy
to Indonesia—they continued their work, providing cheap milk and meals to
struggling families, distributing tens of thousands of boxed meals across
Jakarta.
They raised over a billion rupiahs through grassroots
donations, proving that effective activism isn’t just about making noise—it’s
about making a difference in people’s daily lives.
---
For Americans, there’s something familiar in these stories.
We’ve seen our own versions: the civil rights mothers who stood on courthouse
steps demanding justice for their murdered children, their dignity intact even
as hatred raged around them. The Mothers Against Drunk Driving who transformed
unspeakable personal grief into a national crusade that saved countless lives.
There’s a pattern here, a truth that transcends geography
and culture: authoritarian regimes can silence newspapers, jail students, ban
political parties, disappear intellectuals and activists. But they have a much
harder time silencing mothers carrying photographs of their children, or women
handing out milk and flowers in the heart of their capital cities.
Because mothers tap into something primal, something that
cuts through political rhetoric and reaches straight into the human heart. We
all had mothers. We understand, on a cellular level, the fierce protective
instinct that drives a woman to stand in a public square week after week, year
after year, demanding answers that may never come.
The lesson echoes across continents and decades: reform
doesn’t always come from the barrel of a gun or the roar of an angry crowd.
Sometimes it comes from the steady steps of women who refuse to be silenced,
who understand that the most ordinary roles can spark the most extraordinary
changes.
In Argentina, in Indonesia, and in countless other places
where darkness has tried to swallow the light, mothers have stood as sentinels
against forgetting. They’ve proven that love—fierce, uncompromising, maternal
love—can be the most powerful force for change in a world that too often
mistakes cruelty for strength.
Because in the end, that’s what this is about: love. Love
that refuses to give up, love that won’t be silenced, love that stands in
public squares carrying photographs and demanding justice until the very stones
cry out for mercy.
And sometimes, just sometimes, love wins.
Comments
Post a Comment